eruthros: Delenn from Babylon 5 with a startled expression and the text "omg!" (Default)
[personal profile] eruthros
Comment on a bit of a article about Buffy (not the anti-Spike one, but Bye-bye, Buffy! It's an interesting article in many ways.

The notoriously possessive Buffy fan base is consistent in that it invariably dislikes the current season. They hated it when Buffy's best friend Willow (Alyson Hannigan) abandoned her lifelong crush on fellow Scooby gang member Xander (Nicholas Brendon) for a relationship with Oz (Seth Green) -- though they later developed a passionate attachment to Willow's new boyfriend. They hated it when Angel (David Boreanaz) left Sunnydale for Los Angeles (and his own series). They hated it when the Scooby gang left high school, and then they hated it when Buffy left college for the tedium of the working world in order to support her sister Dawn (Michelle Trachtenberg) after their mother's death. They hated it when Buffy came back from the dead after the climactic self-sacrifice that ended Season 5 and was understandably addled and depressed as a result. And since she's gotten over that, they don't like the fact that in Season 7 she's become, in the words of one devotee I know, "a total bitch."

If I may: I didn't hate most of that. I watched in real-time, from season one, and I know the name of pretty much every episode.I remember Buffy's cool walk-in-white-prom-dress that closed season one, and I remember watching Buffy kill Angel, and I remember being shocked at the wonderful sword-grabbing. So I think I count as a fan.

I liked Oz. I was glad Willow had gotten over her unreturned crush and was dating someone who appreciated her. I was so incredibly stoked when Angel left it's hard to describe now. I liked the Scoobies in college in 4th season. I didn't hate that Buffy left college for the working world; I hated it that she had such a ridiculously stupid job for a high-school graduate in a town with massive attrition, and that we spent so many godawful hours there. It wasn't interesting. I didn't mind the addled and depressed Buffy, but I thought it went on too long.

Mostly, I get tetchy about moments that I feel are too contrived. See "Tara dies to give Willow an excuse to go evil," for example. I mean, Willow has a perfectly legitimate reason to go evil: she's power hungry and lacks confidence. You could build on that and it would actually look like character development. Also, as this journalist notes "The creators of imaginary worlds know that they have to stick to their own invented rules." So I get tetchy when they don't -- what does magic stand for? What's the slayer-power deal again? And I get tetchy when the plot doesn't make sense or people don't follow up on it (which is why the X-files eventually started to drive me bonkers).

But I remember watching the second season finale and thinking "wow, how could they top this?" And then they did, in season three -- Faith! The mayor! An invulnerable enemy! Mr. Trick! Dopelgangland! Band Candy! Whee!

But then season five? Well, Dawn was bratty. Without being interesting. She's since gotten better, but dude, there are plenty of people like that in Real Life. At least Cordelia was bitchy in an entertaining way. And when will Joss Whedon find out that having people on the show make fun of character flaws doesn't mean we want to see the flaws? Like, say, Kennedy's "I'm a brat" or Andrew's "Buffy's doing a boring speech, let's cut away." It doesn't help us suffer through the rest of the boring speeches or the bitchiness.

So, dude, stop claiming that people who have problems with a show are unreasonable. There are bigger plot holes in season seven, I think, than there were in season three or four. There are bigger continuity problems (um, yes. the open Initiative, for example.). I'm not an idiot; I'm watching the show with an eye towards narrative flow. And I see bigger problems. Like, actual problems, not just "oh, she's being another one of those stupid fans who hates every current season." So I wish people who Adore Every Moment of the show (and that's cool; they're welcome to; people have different viewing styles) would stop hassling us less-adulating fans as "only liking the old stuff" and "being unreasonable."

Anonymous (will be screened)
OpenID (will be screened if not validated)
Identity URL: 
Account name:
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.


If you are unable to use this captcha for any reason, please contact us by email at

Notice: This account is set to log the IP addresses of everyone who comments.
Links will be displayed as unclickable URLs to help prevent spam.


eruthros: Delenn from Babylon 5 with a startled expression and the text "omg!" (Default)

May 2017

2829 3031   

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Oct. 21st, 2017 02:46 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios