eruthros: SG1: Daniel Jackson, text: "I never wanted to be an archaeologist... I wanted to be a lumberjack!"  (SG1 - A Lumberjack!)
[personal profile] eruthros
Okay, this is really starting to bug me: what kind of economic structure did the Ancients on Atlantis have?

If they were capitalists, why haven't we seen delivery systems into the apartments, or replicators, or shops? Where are the Ancient implants or ATMs or biometric readers or other scientific thingamabobs that would let the Ancients buy things? The Ancients clearly didn't strip Atlantis entirely, so we should be able to recognize stores from shape and design and, presumably, a little bit of stock left. And Rodney would be on any kind of replicator or instant-delivery system in seconds, and making Star Trek jokes the whole time. The place is the size of Manhattan; where did the Ancients buy white robes or hair product or neat kicky boots or tea or personalized puddle-jumpers with fuzzy dice in the windows?

And since we don't see any of that, I have to ask: were the Ancient socialists? But if they were, where were their food production centers? Was there central planning that determined which roots to really focus on growing this year? Were there Ancient farms? How did they decide who got which quarters? Did they have a commons system? Did they have population pressures on said system?

Did they barter with other Pegasus galaxy dudes? If so, what did they barter? Because they don't seem to have a labor force that's producing anything. Where are the Ancient factories? (Or replicators. I'd take replicators. Though then I'd be wondering where there were replicators big enough to build the Stargates.)

(Ooooh! They should have a gift economy! With aggrandizing individuals giving away more than they get and being regarded as leaders! There could be huge feasts, and gift exchange, and ties of obligation and reciprocity. But that still doesn't solve the problem of where they're getting the things they are giving away.)

Who supported the Ancients when they were attempting to attain Ascension via endless meditation?

(This bugs me in the Ori galaxy too, though not as much: the followers of the Ori spend how much of the day in prayer? Six hours a day? So, what, do they have the most fertile land ever? Or are the Priors wandering around and doing the weeding and milking for them?)

I know, I know. Suck it up and handwave.

Date: 2006-08-06 03:58 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile]
My husband, who's getting his MBA right now, thought you asked good questions.

I pointed out to him that SGA seems to require a *lot* more handwaving than SG1, perhaps because SG1 is based on Earth, in our military, in our time.

I remember first seeing the city and being impressed with how beautiful it was, and those stained glass windows, and then I discovered that it's a glass shell (a lot like the characters, actually), pretty to look at, but empty and unfinished on the inside.

Gives fanfic writers a lot to do, but I find it more and more annoying to watch because my hand just gets so tired from waving.

Date: 2006-08-06 06:03 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile]
Hah! This has bugged the heck out of me too. I want to see an abandoned production plant, dammit. I want an SGA gate team to stumble across something and go, hey, this must be where they got the materials to build all of these Ancient cities we keep running across out here!

You know what I've wondered? If maybe the reason they 'seeded' the Pegasus galaxy with humans is so that they'd have a workforce. They'd have people out there producing food, possibly mining and refining minerals, and all the Ancients would have to do is barter for it all. Except, like you say, what would they have to give?

Or possibly they'd demand the humans provide them with stuff - after all, enough of the human populations they've run across hold the Ancestors in reverence to imply that maybe the Ancients played themselves off as benevolent dieties or rulers. I mean, hey, maybe that's where the Ori got the idea from? The Ancients used to pull a god scam on the primitive humans when they were stuck in corporeal form; why not take it to the next level once they've ascended and got *real* power?



eruthros: Delenn from Babylon 5 with a startled expression and the text "omg!" (Default)

May 2017

2829 3031   

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Oct. 21st, 2017 03:11 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios